Evaluating Existing OER
As an instructor you are used to evaluating the resources you use in your courses. Some of the evaluation criteria listed below are universal, and others (such as Adaptability and Modularity) are specific to OER.
Clarity, comprehensibility, and readability
The most ubiquitous standard on this list is also the first: can the material you are considering be read and understood by your students?
Considerations:
- Is the content, including any instructions and exercises, clear and comprehensible to students?
- Is the content consistent with its language and formatting? (e.g. key terms are bold)
- Is the content well-organized in terms of sequencing and flow?
Content and technical accuracy
The accuracy of the content you use is also a major component of its usability in the classroom. Be sure to check for technical errors such as broken links or typos. In most cases, content accuracy will not be an issue, but some older resources may require updates.
Considerations:
- Is the content accurate based on your expertise?
- Are there any factual, grammatical, or typographical errors?
- Is the interface navigable for students?
Adaptability and modularity
Because of their open licenses, OER permit a wider range of (re)use than most traditional educational content; therefore, it is important to keep in mind how your chosen OER can be adapted.
Considerations:
- Does the license allow for modifications? (Note that we will be talking more about licenses in the next workshop).
- Is the material itself conducive to modularity, or the ability to be broken up into smaller pieces easily should be preferred when possible?
- Can it be easily divided into modules, or sections, which can be used or rearranged out of their original order?
- Are there clear chapter and unit breaks can help other instructors adopting or adapting your resource for their own courses?
- Is the material formatted for adaptations, modifications, rearrangements, and updates?
Appropriateness and fit
Open licenses of OER mean that they can be edited or even combined with other resources. This can be particularly useful if you would like to adopt a chapter from one OER for the first unit of your course but prefer alternate resources for other units.
Considerations:
- Is the content presented at a reading level appropriate for your students?
- How does the content align with your course learning objectives?
- Is the content level appropriate for use in your course?